A nerdy waltz (now with some sheets)

[nerd]

Now that the CF composing contest is over I might as well put my piece here. I have no good reason why I chose "nerdywaltz" as filename... Anyway, it was voted 3rd

http://www.chopinforum.com/~nerd/nerdywaltz.mp3

--
DDN

[Scriabinist]

Yar, this weas my favourite in the contest...Too bad it got only 3rd. I'm assuming it's even playable unlie many other amateur compositions I see.

[nerd]

Yar, this weas my favourite in the contest...

Too bad it got only 3rd.

I'm assuming it's even playable unlie many other amateur compositions I see.

Yes. It's note even so hard. I'm planning to make the sheets for it in the near future, too (once I learn LilyPond a bit better)

--
DDN

[Comme_le_Vent]

hahahaha, respec for turnin da gayest possible form into a wikid sausage-fest

dis is actually wikid, i wonda what da FOOK got da 1st place

it bettah be fookin gurd

[Comme_le_Vent]

lso - i detected a finnish influence at da end - when it......finnished

[Sohcahtoa]

I like it a lot! Very nice and pleasant work.

[PianistSk8er]

Very nice! I like it a lot!

If only I could hear the melody more than the left hand banging loudly, that would be my only complaint.

Also, why is it nerdy?

87 from me, I love it!

PS

[ChopinBallade]

roberts op 6 got first...i think it was the right choice for 1st...it is a really good comp

[nerd]

Thanks for liking it

If only I could hear the melody more than the left hand banging loudly, that would be my only complaint.

Also, why is it nerdy?

Maybe when I get the sheets done and you can follow from it you can hear it more clearly. I could of course try to make a better version of it, too.

It's nerdy because a nerd made it I just quicly decided for a filename and happened to call it nerdywaltz.mp3.

--
DDN

[WinterWind_23]

Quite good. It's really waltzy, but candidly, there is nothing really special about. It's better than my compositions, but there is nothign that jumps out of the listener.

[TheRach]

Holy crap
95 from me, man.

[Amnesia]

Very nice! If only I could hear the melody more than the left hand banging loudly, that would be my only complaint.
PS

I agree with PS, the left hand should be a lot softer and less mechanical. You could really make this into a beautiful recording. I really like the composition though.

95 for composition
75 for execution
85 OVERALL

[nerd]

I agree with PS, the left hand should be a lot softer and less mechanical. You could really make this into a beautiful recording. I really like the composition though.

95 for composition
75 for execution
85 OVERALL

First, this is a composing forum, so you shouldn't rate 'execution'
Secondly, it's not a recording, but a midi I played and recorded to mp3 (with a soundfont to get a bit better sound)

--
DDN

[nerd]

I've made some sort of sheetmusic for this. It has notes and some articulation marks anly and it's a bit messy at some spots; you have to come up with your own phrasing and dynamics and such if you're going to play it

http://www.chopinforum.com/~nerd/nerdywaltz.pdf

--
DDN

[Amnesia]

I agree with PS, the left hand should be a lot softer and less mechanical. You could really make this into a beautiful recording. I really like the composition though.

95 for composition
75 for execution
85 OVERALL

First, this is a composing forum, so you shouldn't rate 'execution'
Secondly, it's not a recording, but a midi I played and recorded to mp3 (with a soundfont to get a bit better sound)

--
DDN

Sorry nerd, I didn't realise it was a midi recording. I'd like to hear your recording of this piece. Although composing is only half the battle, playing it well is the other half , I hereby change my rating to 95 for a brilliant composition Thanks for the sheet, it doesn't look easy to play, but I'm sure it would sound wonderful with some expression and interpretation